Reviews > Soil-test dynamics throughout a five-year 'Thompson Farm'...

Soil-test dynamics throughout a five-year 'Thompson Farm' rotation in Iowa

Douglas L. Karlen,Keith A. Kohler,David A. Laird,Richard L. Thompson,Douglas D. Buhler
American Journal of Alternative Agriculture, 2002, Vol. 17, No. 1, pp. 9-17, 25 ref.
March 2002

Soil-testing is an effective guide for achieving and maintaining an optimum supply of available plant nutrients, but there is little information on the multi-year soil-test changes for farms using long-term crop rotations, ridge-tillage and nutrients supplied by a mixture of organic amendments. Our objectives were to characterize yearly changes in surface soil-test parameters, including the stratification of P and K; compare soil-test methods (Mehlich III versus Bray P1 and 1 M NH4 OAc Exchangeable K); and evaluate soil-test interpretation strategies [sufficiency level versus basic cation saturation ratio (BCSR)] within a farmer- managed field. The study was conducted on the Clarion-Nicollet-Webster Soil Association near Boone, IA, in a field that had not been moldboard plowed for 29 years. Soil samples were collected from the 0±5, 5±10, 10±15, and 15±20 cm depth increments before plowing and every autumn thereafter throughout the 5±year rotation. Samples were analyzed for pH, Bray extractable P, exchangeable K, total C and N, NH4 - and NO3 -N concentrations, and Mehlich III extractable P, K, Ca, Mg, Na, Mn and Zn. Stratification of P and K was evident within 2 years after moldboard plowing. This was not considered a production problem, because, based on sufficiency-level soil-test interpretations, the animal manure/municipal sludge applications had increased soil P and K concentrations to levels where no crop response to additional fertilizer would be expected. Using Mehlich III extractant with simultaneous inductively coupled plasma-atomic emission spectrometer (ICP-AES) analysis resulted in soil-test interpretations that were the same as with Bray P1 and 1 M ammonium acetate (NH4 OAc) extracting solutions. The Mehlich III solution did extract more Ca than 1 M NH4 OAc, causing K saturation percentages to be very low when the data were interpreted using a BCSR approach. We conclude that stratification is not a production issue at this site; that either soil-test methodology would be acceptable for P and K extraction; and that additional studies evaluating the BCSR soil-test interpretation philosophy are warranted.